Before reading, please extend your valuable hand and click on 'Follow'. We hope it can bring you a different reading experience

Before reading, please extend your valuable hand and click on 'Follow'. We hope it can bring you a different reading experience. You can discuss and share in the comments section. Thank you for your support!

Archaeological Exploration

Editor | Archaeological Exploration

preface

I strongly demand the abolition of traditional Chinese medicine. Traditional Chinese medicine cannot be eradicated, and nature cannot tolerate it

This remark immediately caused a heated debate on the Internet, and many netizens were very indignant. Some netizens even pointed out that they would check the person's background. However, it was not others who said this, but Zhang Gongyao, a philosophy professor at Central South University.

In addition, Zhang Gongyao also launched a campaign of 10000 signatures on the Internet, calling on the state to ban traditional Chinese medicine. His behavior was once again criticized by netizens.

However, surprisingly, someone actually signed their name on this event and threatened that traditional Chinese medicine treatment has no medical basis and should have been banned long ago.

Traditional Chinese medicine, as a treasure that has been passed down in China for five thousand years, is now facing the situation of being banned, which instantly makes people feel extremely heartbroken.

Why did traditional Chinese medicine fall here? Where should traditional Chinese medicine go in the future?

Traditional Chinese Medicine's Theory of Uselessness

?

Zhang Gongyao said that traditional Chinese medicine is just a traditional Chinese culture, not a medical means. He also believed that there is no exact standard for the use of medicine in traditional Chinese medicine. Most of them are "looking, smelling, asking, and feeling", all based on experience, which is irresponsible for patients.

In fact, as early as 2006, Zhang Gongyao had criticized traditional Chinese medicine, and also wrote an article to prove his own point of view. In the article, Zhang Gongyao dismissed traditional Chinese medicine as useless, and even described it as Pseudoscience.

Traditional Chinese Medicine's Theory of Uselessness

In his articles and speeches, Zhang Gongyao not only said that traditional Chinese medicine was useless, but also listed some so-called evidence. He also criticized traditional Chinese medicine and praised western medicine.

?

In fact, at the beginning, Zhang Gongyao also studied Chinese medicine. He wanted to understand the philosophy of Chinese medicine, so he saw a lot of ancient Chinese medicine. It was also at this time that he found the problems in Chinese medicine.

When he studied these medical techniques in depth, he was often puzzled by the prescriptions in the book. For example, in Li Shizhen's Compendium of Materia Medica, he found a local way to treat children's crying.

In medical books, it is written that when a child cries in the middle of the night, a bundle of pig ropes can be burned into ashes and mixed with water to feed the child, which can cure "the child's sudden crying and restlessness".

The "toilet preparation" mentioned in the book is actually what people often refer to as a fecal stirring stick. The book records that fumigating the fecal stirring stick under the bed can treat difficult childbirth and cholera.

Such "prescriptions" made Zhang Gongyao suspicious of traditional Chinese medicine. He believed that this was the same as those "Fu Shui" which pretended to be supernatural, and it was the filth of the feudal era.

If you look carefully, you will find that when Zhang Gongyao criticizes the uselessness of traditional Chinese medicine, he stands in the perspective of modern medicine. When Western medicine conducts treatment, it will carry out various examinations, finally determine the condition, and then prescribe medicine according to the amount.

But he believes that the prescription of traditional Chinese medicine is entirely based on his own experience, without a standard for measurement, and there is no scientific basis for pulse monitoring. The most commonly used method, "observing, listening, inquiring, and cutting," is not enough to understand the patient's condition. Therefore, he believes that traditional Chinese medicine is not responsible for the patient at this time.

In addition, he also believes that most of the drugs prescribed by traditional Chinese medicine are for regulating and maintaining health, and do not play a crucial role in the patient's condition. Therefore, he calls on relevant national departments to remove traditional Chinese medicine from the country's medical system and calls on the people of the whole country to resist traditional Chinese medicine.

In response, the Ministry of Health condemned and criticized Zhang Gongyao's ignorance and misdeeds, and affirmed that TCM played an important role in medicine and national development.

Since then, Zhang Gongyao was expelled from Central South University.

However, this has brought a wake-up call to people that traditional Chinese medicine should be taken seriously!

Traditional Chinese Medicine Culture

The most proud part of China's 5000 year history is the various treasures that have been passed down. These treasures are a reflection of Chinese civilization and a symbol of Chinese culture.

In particular, Chinese medicine has a history of five thousand years, and many "miracle doctors" have appeared in the history, such as Hua Tuo, Bian Que, Sun Simiao, and so on. They are all famous physicians in China.

According to the ancient document Lunheng, during the Urgesellschaft in the agricultural era, people still lived a primitive life, and raw meat and wild fruits were their main sources of life.

Therefore, people at that time often suffered poisoning and died, so their lifespan was usually very short. As the leader of the Immortal Clan, the Shennong clan couldn't bear to see the suffering of their own people, so they began to search for good medicine that could treat diseases for the people.

He traveled mountains and rivers, traveled all over the land of Sanxiang, tasted all kinds of herbs, and recorded in detail the medicinal properties of each herb, which brought great help to the people's diseases. Later, the Shennong family mistakenly ate the Heartbroken Grass during a taste of herbs, and unfortunately died.

Later, according to their records, people carefully pondered, and later generations gradually made these drugs into a "book" for inheritance. This book is the Shennong Ben Cao Jing.

The Shennong Ben Cao Jing is the earliest Chinese herbal medicine in China, and even many later herbal scriptures are all based on it. It has played a significant role and influence on the development of Chinese medicine in China.

In addition to the famous "Shennong Tastes a Hundred Herbs", there is also the miraculous doctor Bianque, who was the pioneer of traditional Chinese medicine "looking, smelling, inquiring, and cutting". However, the authenticity of Bianque has always been controversial in the academic community.

According to relevant historical records, the activity time span of the flat magpie is too long, lasting for hundreds of years, which experts believe completely violates the law of people's lifespan.

In addition, some of Bian Que's treatment methods are too avant-garde, much like the handwriting of modern people. It is said that Bian Que has also undergone Heart transplantation, so some people suspect that Bian Que may be a passer-by.

But the flat magpie with such a high level of art has never been passed down in medical history, which is also one of the reasons why people suspect its authenticity.

In Chengdu, Sichuan, an ancient tomb was unexpectedly excavated, and a large number of medical slips were unearthed. Among these medical slips, it was found that the author of this medical slip was named "Benxi". After expert interpretation, "Benxi" was written in the style of "Bianque" at that time.

Later, after years of dedicated research by experts, this medical brief contained many core medical theories, and over 100 prescriptions for treating diseases had been lost for a long time.

Also mentioned above is the Compendium of Materia Medica, which was criticized by Zhang Gongyao. When Li Shizhen was compiling it, he wrote all kinds of strange "prescriptions" in the world in addition to his own medical experience.

This is because he believes that medicine is a very magical thing, many things he cannot even see through, and there are also many strange medicinal herbs in the world.

Therefore, in the Compendium of Materia Medica, there are many strange prescriptions that he collected throughout the country, with the aim of enabling future generations to study the principles behind them.

The Compendium of Materia Medica covers a wide range of content, not only as a medicinal work, but also as a work on natural history, with great influence worldwide.

But Zhang Gongyao didn't even understand the meaning of this "Great Classic of Oriental Medicine", so he talked shamelessly about boycotting traditional Chinese medicine. He really didn't understand what philosophical content this "professor" could give students.

The Status of Traditional Chinese Medicine

However, Chinese medicine, which Zhang Gongyao despises, is very popular abroad. Even the American army will use the acupuncture and moxibustion technology of Chinese medicine to alleviate the pain of soldiers.

Just as Chinese people are still questioning traditional Chinese medicine, according to incomplete statistics, there are over 8000 traditional Chinese medicine clinics in the United States, and more and more Americans are feeling that "mysterious power from the East".

In addition to the United States, Japan, Japan's authoritative medical expert Keiji Otsuka specifically told his students before his death that they must learn from China modestly. Ten years later, China will learn from Japan.

?

What is even more heartbreaking is that some Chinese medicine companies in China have even been acquired by Japanese companies, and the Japanese have also taken away our traditional Chinese medicine formulas and technologies.

Traditional Chinese Medicine Culture

Zhang Gongyao often compares modern medicine with traditional Chinese medicine and belittles traditional Chinese medicine as useless. However, in modern medicine, many medical concepts of traditional Chinese medicine are integrated, such as traditional Chinese patent medicines and simple preparations.

In addition to the fact that Chinese people don't pay attention to the decline of TCM, there is also a cruel situation that TCM is too "cheap". Some diseases can be treated by acupuncture and moxibustion and moxibustion of TCM, which costs only a few yuan, and can easily be hundreds of thousands to go to the hospital.

Therefore, in many modern general hospitals, the acupuncture and moxibustion department has been closed because it can not bring "economic benefits" to hospitals, which is one of the reasons for the decline of TCM.

There is a phenomenon in today's society that makes people feel quite funny. Many pharmacies often carry out activities in order to achieve good results, and they will give away some things according to the amount of money they spend, such as cooking oil, eggs, etc.

Since ancient times, traditional Chinese medicine has always valued righteousness over profit, and often there are literati who prefer to use medicine to generate dust, hoping for no suffering in the world. This may also be one of the reasons for the decline of traditional Chinese medicine.

epilogue

Traditional Chinese medicine is one of the cultural treasures of our country. It is the "essence" rather than the "dross". It should be inherited and carried forward, rather than criticized and rejected. Traditional Chinese medicine should not be abolished, let alone banned.

Whether it is traditional Chinese medicine or Western medicine, their purpose is to treat diseases and alleviate disasters for the people. They should not be compared, as they each have their own advantages and gradually complement each other in the development of society.

As children of China, we should carry forward the traditional culture left by our ancestors, which is the wisdom of the ancients. Every Chinese people should inherit and carry forward it.

After reading this article, please follow and comment so that you can quickly follow any new developments in the remaining events

Previous Highlights

Even more righteous than Ba Tie! Directly move the entire production line to China, and package and transfer all core technologies

2650?

?2

Disclaimer: The content of this article is sourced from the internet. The copyright of the text, images, and other materials belongs to the original author. The platform reprints the materials for the purpose of conveying more information. The content of the article is for reference and learning only, and should not be used for commercial purposes. If it infringes on your legitimate rights and interests, please contact us promptly and we will handle it as soon as possible! We respect copyright and are committed to protecting it. Thank you for sharing.(Email:[email protected])